Skip to main content

Methodology · savings

How a saving is proven

This page says what CloudJaeger counts as a saving it has proven, how that saving is measured on your bill, and what never counts.

What proven means

  • A saving is called verified only when CloudJaeger's own inventory shows the resource changed, and the bill measured it before and after that moment.

  • A change is recorded in one of two ways: a pull request CloudJaeger opened that a person merged, or a change your team marks completed after making it in the console or elsewhere.

  • A merge or a completion alone is not proof: the inventory has to show the resource deleted, or with a different type, size or class than when the change was recorded.

  • A change the inventory has not shown within 45 days is not verified, whatever the bill did.

  • Until then a saving is an estimate: the Action Center counts it as identified, accepted or self-reported, never as verified.

  • A change your team marks done stays self-reported, at its estimate, until the inventory shows it: nothing is verified on anyone's word.

  • Rejecting a recommendation needs a reason, and an approval keeps the name of the person who gave it.

  • Coming: the first saving verified on a real customer bill — none has been graded on one yet.

  • Coming: savings verified on Azure and Google Cloud — their billing data does not yet name each resource, so a change there cannot be measured on its own.

How a saving is measured on the bill

  • The bill is read for the 30 days before the change and the 30 days after it, and both windows must be fully covered by settled bill before any figure is stated.

  • The change is dated by the inventory reading that first showed it, not by the merge or the day it was marked completed.

  • The newest 2 days of bill are left out, because providers still restate them.

  • A dollar is claimed only when the bill names the changed resource and no other recorded change touched it in the same window.

  • An AWS bill may name a resource by its ARN or by its short id, such as i-0abc or vol-0abc, and a short id counts only inside the resource's own account and region.

  • A change is not graded while another pull request on the same resource may have merged without CloudJaeger reading it yet.

  • When the bill only shows a whole service, the movement is reported but no dollar is claimed.

  • One resource's bill is read once, even when a payer account and the member account both hold a copy of it.

  • A window billed in a currency other than US dollars is not measured.

  • A window with rows that were converted to US dollars when they were uploaded is not measured either.

  • A movement inside the noise floor, the larger of $1 a month and 2% of the baseline, is reported as no measurable change.

How commitments are netted

  • A saving is measured on the resource's usage priced on demand, not on usage a reservation, savings plan or committed-use discount covered.

  • The commitment is still paid after the change, so the part of the drop it covered is never claimed.

  • A resource that ran entirely under a commitment shows no measured saving, not a saving of $0.

  • Negotiated percentage discounts, such as an enterprise discount, move with usage and are included.

  • Coming: credit for a freed commitment that goes on to cover other usage.

What never counts

  • A credit, refund or tax line on the resource is never counted as a saving.

  • A figure someone typed in, such as a commitment saving entered by hand, is shown but never added to the verified total.

  • A change that made the bill go up is shown as regressed and is never netted against savings.

  • When several recorded changes touch one resource in the same window, none of them claims the dollar, so one movement is never counted twice.

  • A change measured from its pull request or its inventory reading is not measured again by the check of changes your team marked done.

The rest of the engineering behind the numbers is on /methodology, and what each module can prove today is on /evidence.